Of course its possible... but problem is users already get lost in the myriad of options available in the admin... and we tend to subscribe to the WordPress mantra which is 'decisions, not options'... that is provide a set of predefined attributes, but allow them to be modified by hook if needed...
and then you get into, remove all the stats... or remove one item of the stats... or remove these two items... or remove all but this one... or etc etc... the possible combinations are very, very many... hard to draw a line - so we have at the basics...
adding an extra check on option would also slow down every single page load for the vast majority that do show the stats.. yes, very small amount, but slower none the less...
another one of those cases of providing a default action that supports 90% or more of the masses... but of course, not 100%... hence the support via actions... or in this case, simple commenting out of a section of the theme template file... we have also provided starter child themes for all of our themes... its not harder than downloading, selecting as your theme, copying the spFooter.php template file and commenting out the stats stuff... we can certainly walk you through it...
we certainly do understand your situation, but at this time, we do not have plans for such an option... that said, we are always listening to suggestions from our users and continually re-evaluate the various decisions...
thanks for your input!